17th-century American Women: Jamestown - The Moment of Discovery: A Pewter Flagon in a Jamestown Well

How this blog works

About this blog

This blog will focus on how the lives of women living in the British American colonies on the Atlantic coast changed over the 17th century. I will try to use first-hand accounts whenever possible; so that the reader can compare & contrast those changes over time.

History is certainly not a science. It is not the absolute truth. It is constantly changing as new evidence & new interpretations flash into view. As those looking at history peel away the tired, old suppositions, they add new (but soon to grow old) assumptions of their own.

History reflects not just the prejudices of the period under study, but also the biases of those studying it. Since each person who focuses on a historical period brings a different perspective to the task, historians often interpret the same period of the past in vastly different ways.

History before 1800 is often skewed; because only the few, the powerful, and the wealthy kept written records of events. And yet, events only advance & take a particular shape, because of the everyday actions of the nameless many who give them the energy to move forward.

beeskep@gmail.com

Using Primary Sources

This blog will use as much original evidence as possible to allow the reader to draw conclusions.

Primary sources can give us a sense of the real differences between the past and the present; a context for understanding how ideas came about at a certain place in time; a realization that there are few neat linear narratives; a recognition of how our concept of the past has been shaped by people who have written about it.

Primary sources are documents or artifacts created during the time being studied or shortly after by a participant as a memoir. They are infused with the fleeting spirit of the time in which they were created. First-hand accounts bring a human voice to history, but they surely do not speak for themselves, they must be interpreted.

Primary sources force us to ask what those who created these surviving records must have believed or desired or deemed valuable in order to understand their ideas and actions.

Primary sources urge us to question the historical conclusions of others. For a study of 17th century America, surviving manuscripts, letters, diaries, & journals; ship logs; court, church & land records; and artifacts such as portraits & archaelogical finds, are the original evidence needed to compile good history.

Good history results from the examination of countless primary sources to reach a general conclusion about a time period or event. Good history is not deciding a conclusion in advance and then picking only those sources which support that foregone interpretation.

The "least-best" theory of collecting the least amount of the best evidence to construct a convincing argument about an issue may be expedient in mathematics, but it does not work well in any serious study of history. Without gathering a hefty quantity of primary source evidence, how can the historian determine which is the best evidence?

Good history is not based on one or two anecdotal incidents or descriptions manipulated into a generalized conclusion about the whole.

In this blog, we will be looking at snippets of history. Exploring individual anecdotal incidents may be fun; but they are not good history, until they are woven into the whole.

Museums, Libraries, & Historic Sites

For years before I had to rely on my computer to read text or travel from place to place, I longed for a way to see images of paintings from various artists side by side to compare & contrast their works, as they changed over time & with the works of other artists.

Using the jpegs allowed me to do this on my large-screen computer with ease. I could group the slides in any way I wanted to study, compare, & contrast them. Those back-lit slide boxes just didn't do it for me.

Those computer images became my uber museum, nothing like seeing paintings in person, but infinitely better than not seeing them at all.

And, of course, now I realize more than ever before, that there are many people who cannot and do not go to museums, historic sites, & libraries for any number of reasons. They might be handicapped, intimidated, confined to their homes, or simply working hard to maintain their families without enough extra money to travel.

For many, a computer at home or at a local library is their only access to art & history.

Most historic sites, historical societies, museums, & libraries are incorporated as non-profit organizations which exist to collect, preserve, and study America's history & to share it with others.

They do not exist to make a profit by limiting the use of their collections only to those who can afford to pay or to those who have the luxury of being able to travel & to walk.

Most do charge admissions, fees, & sell items to make money in order to research, maintain & expand their collections & share them through education programs & websites.

17th-century American Women

Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Jamestown - The Moment of Discovery: A Pewter Flagon in a Jamestown Well

0 comments: